Why there no more review?

[Berni]

Why? i post a new skin and there no review! I want review so like that i can learn what is not good enough to get 5 stars......cause my last skin i posted is rated 3 stars and im kinda ANGRY!!!! Only cause i dont know why 3 stars!

Anyway, why?

[Anacific]

Try to post your skin on http://www.skinz.org/ You'll get a review faster ;)

[a-arse]

But If you want to know why It's because the Good people at nullsoft are too busy making a brand spanking new mp3 player.

[randman]

Aren't they in the process of changing the reviewing system to one that lets member/users rank them? (Finally). ;)

And shouldn't this post be moved to the "Share Your Skin Love" forum?

And if you want an honest review of your skin, post a link. I'll "review" it for you. ;)

[edit] Nevermind. I see you do Anime skins. Do you use original artwork created by yourself? Just curious. [edit]

[Berni]

Randman..

Nope, this pic if from "INITIAL D" an anime on racing cars, but all the rest is from me, i mean all the effect and everything, i would like to be able to do nice 3D render like that....but im not enough good!

[randman]

In my opinion, anime, photo, image skins, or whatever you want to call them are deserving of 3 stars at best. And that is only if you created the image, photo, or art yourself. Using other peoples artwork or photos without getting their permission is called copyright infringement. (Or as I like to call it, theft).

Why only 3 stars? Because there are skins out there that are created pixel by pixel by "skin artists" like Steve Moss, Pordey, $teven, Fli7e, and hundreds of others. The skins they create are usually deserving of 5 stars.

Besides you reviewed yourself already, and I quote: "i would like to be able to do nice 3D render like that....but im not enough good!" What I am saying is, your skins are those of a fairly new skinner. Keep practicing and try using original ideas and artwork. Then you'll get better. My intention is not to discourage you from skinning, but to learn to become a better skinner. OK? :)


Again, that's just my opinion and I'm standing by it. :)

[Berni]

Well randman, i dont think you're right cause i already have 2 skin rated at 4 stars and both of them are from a pic that i dont made....like this one, i think using a pic and making a skin on it that fit well it another kind of artwork, it not always easy to skin a pic and keep the pic alive and fun to watch!

It why i dont think i deserv 3 stars, anyway we can see 5 stars skin that are only a pic of a person and ppl add some effect that we already saw somewhere! For my part i try to make my skin alive!