A simple review question. Public Opinion PLS!
 

I submitted a skin, which got a rating of 3 for completeness. I could understand that if this skin was used as a 3.x skin, but it was submitted as a 2.x skin. AND EVERY ASPECT IS SKINNED. So I don't understand the reason behind it.

Please check it out people, and tell me what you think!

http://www.winamp.com/components/det...onentId=118631

http://www.winamp.com/components/arc...ngine_Lime.jpg

mixed in with completeness is the functionality rating, you have a nice complex skin, but the complexity can take of from the functionality.

woah.. thats a bright one. it looks like it passed the bevel machine test ok ;)

Nice skin. :up: The rating seems kinda low.

hey, i also found that that skin had way too low of a rating,
by the way tone down that green that next time around, its abit too bright for most pple (in my oppinion that is)

oh ya, by the way i was the reviewer "jacob aspler"

Thanks guys...for a second there I thought that I (and Jacob) were the only people who like it...it being my second skin, I was discouraged and shot down enough almost never to skin again...

BUT I'll make a darker version and resubmit it.

Yeah, I definately think this skin deserves more than three-and-a-half stars. It's complex, aesthetic and looks like you guys put a lot of work into it. I'd give it four-and-a-half.