everyone's a critic........
 

This is how it works......Post a track, the person below will give a

:up:
or
:down:

and a rating.... ie;

BRMC - Spread Your Love
:up: 10/10

Obviously, prepare to be disappointed, but don't take a :down: to heart...

Rush - Tom Sawyer

:up:
I simply love that song 10/10

Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here

:up:

10/10

all pink floyd is simply just good.

tangerine dream - tyger

:up:
10/10 (based on intuition)

A not so easy one then...

Def Leppard - Animal

:down:
50 Cent - P.I.M.P.

:down: :down:

1/1 not my kind of music at all

japan- gentleman take polaroids

Yer they are ok. :up:
8/10

Foo Fighters - All My Life

Foo Fighters are overated. Plus, the lead singer (ex Nirvana dude) is way too tall.
:down: 4/10

The Darkness - Growing On Me

9/10 :up:
excellent

Stone Roses - Made Of Stone

Same again. People say 'The Roses are way overated'. Well, so are The Beatles.
:up: 9/10

Aqua - Barbie Girl

* shots ring out through the forum
0/10

Ozzy Osbourne - Mr Crowley

:( Barbie Girl's a great track!

I don't like the Osbornes show (or the hype). So....
:down:2/10

The Shamen - Move Any Mountain

Tis one of those old songs from when ozzy was... good. Anyway the solos involved were quite substantial for my liking but you're entitled to your opinion so... moving swiftly on.

(i still hate that song :p)

anyway:
quickly downloaded about half of it, not really my style of music, so
3/10

David Bowie - Ashes To Ashes

:up:10/10

Suddenly Bowie's a New Romantic...:eek:

Pixies - Debaser

:confused:
Not really a fan of the pixies, but I don't mind em so much.
5/10

Pardise Lost - Erased

Doom metal ain't to my taste, It's not the music - it's the yelling...

:down:3/10

Tom Petty - Free Falling

Mmmmm... I love that song
8/10

It really ain't a doom/death metal actually. More of a rock with slight got overtones.

Toadies - Possum Kingdom

What about the Paradise Lost vocals? Do they at any point erupt into throat-blistered yelling?

Toadies - that's 2 bands in a row I haven't heard of. I suppose grunge has its merits.....

:up:7/10

Sisters of Mercy - Lucretia (My Reflection)

My relection dance the ghost with me :D
Great one!
:up:
8/10
Lil bit off track here.....
It must have been love-Roxette

:up: 7/10 for that one Apola

Pet Shop Boys - It's a Sin

:up: 6/10

not their strongest track

Supertramp - fool's overture

I would've given 'It's a Sin' 10/10:D

Not familiar with that one....
:up:8/10 on their track record

New Order - Blue Monday

:up: 10/10

the first 12" to make it into the charts - a classic

tears for fears - mothers talk

I prefer TFF earlier work.
7/10:up:

Wham! - Wham! Rap

(a bit risky I know)...

:down: :down:
1/1

how dare you post this ( this boy band shit realy got to your mind)

Jethro tull- aqualung

Nein!!!! The lyrics to Wham! Rap are very intelligent, the music is sound. 10/10 material, definitely.:)

I haven't heard any Jethro Tull, but I hear he invented some great farmyard machinery in the 19th Century. So....
8/10:up:

The Cure - The Walk

The Cure are quite nice, havent heard alot though, but ill give them 8/10 :up:

The Vines - Autumn Shade

I haven't heard much of The Vines, but from what I have heard, I'll give them....6/10:up:

Aerosmith - Dream On

I saw Aerosmith on Rage (Music Show) the other night. I didnt like them alot but ill give it 5/10 .:up: :down:

SlipKnoT - New Abortion

I was dreading this moment.....
:down: 1/10

Based 100% on my prejudice. I work at a college, every other student has a SlipKnot t-shirt. Yeah, well.....

You realise I'll be working out an average score (at the foot of the page) so we can see who's got the best taste.:D

Rage Against the Machine - Killing in the Name of

never been a slipknot fan, and that song is nothing extrodinary.
2/10 :down:

the pixies - where is my mind

/edit, whoooops, you beat me too it :P

We may as well go with the moe generous 2/10 then.

:up: 10/10

word

Rage Against the Machine - Killing in the Name of

Yer Rgae is wicked! 10/10:up:

Led Zeppelin - Kashmir

As is Led Zepplin and Kashmir
:up:10/10

BRMC - Stop

Haven't heard alot but they are quite nice, 8/10. :up:

Silverchair - After All These Years

:up: 7/10
I have Frogstomp, and I wasn't impressed. The vocals lack range for one..... Silverchair seem to be very popular for some reason.

The Smiths - What Difference Does It Make?

edit - kulled

GARHHHHHHHHH!!
EVERYONE IS TOO QUICK FOR ME!

Diorama is alot better than Frogstomp, you might like Diorama I think.

The Smiths are good. 9/10:up:

Tool - Aenima

btw, cylob.. silverchair have changed sooooooo much over the years. frogstomp and diorama arnt even the same band. You have to accnowledge that they were 15-16 year old media-puppies when frogstomp came out.

I think you would probably like diorama, it seems like your sort of thing.. ish.. lots of vocal range, lots of bowie-esque over-the-top-ness.

Yer Im with Sidd, go for Diorama, good quality Silverchair.