Not a abusive message But Common, iv seen some really terrable skins get 4 stars. I spend Agers tring to make a skin Look good and whats the result 3 stars like the rest of mine , My last Skin is has gotta be over 3 Come on,
U say, be original -I am and make the Buttons Abit interesting and make then Apart of the Image, Im taling about the A GitS skin here with the Eyepeice As the Shuffle button, Now thats original-and as for the Rest of the Skin I see no probs with it
i even tried to Change the Style i always Make Buttons On the Playlist -Original -they look All worn out (i spent agers on it just thinking of whou i should Position the Pick so the Playlist could merge with the Rest of the Skin, Come on People I demand Better - Ok the Message is the Buttons Arnt Visible enougth -R u Blind or something They all have Boxs around them, Lining it all up took forever and making it was good fun but Sorry the reviewer Must has Somehting against Manga or Ghost in the shell or summet
Whats wrong Ain't it trendy enough. i don't mean to be abusive hear Just I an't Happy

Sorry About the bitchin but Come on
take a look 4 your selfhttp://www.winamp.com/customize/detail.jhtml?componentId=31543
I am the Auther and I feel That an Injustice has taken place

I add this- Did the reviewer Load the skin take 1 look and then write the review- Buttons My ass, """If u press the eyepiece it Lights up""" and is Mached well to the Background-Its Orginal
I have Mates Who Hate manga Who have said That the skin is Amazing Far bettr than alot of Otheres (i gave them copies while it was being reviewed).
I ask for A re-review Coz I think its dawn Out of Order

INCREDIBLY written post using a total of 3 sentences? http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/smile.gif
THIS thread has been done so many times it bores me.-yAWn-

Look through this forum enough and you'll have seen this very topic covered in War and Peace length.
You aren't the first to have and express these opinions, definately won't be the last.
However, big changes are on the horizon, I can feel it.........or was that my knee http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/biggrin.gif

------------------
I don't know Karate......
but I do know Karazy!!!

Yeah, this is the same ol' thing...

But I got some comments for your skin right here. And since I'm a fellow anime skinner myself, we'll see how you take to em:

-The buttons are, BARELY VISABLE. It doesn't matter if you can see them better when they're active. The fact is, that when they're unactive, you can barely see them. Period.

-The numbers are completely unoriginal.

-The volume, balance, and posbars are all floating, and don't really go along with the image (along with a lot of the other skin features).

-The playlist and minibrowser just looks awkward (like at the bottom of the MB...?)

-The skin is very cluttered.

-Most importantly, you did no IMAGE-EDITING. None at all. I usually mess around with multiple images for days before the finished skinable image is ready. Image-editing is a huge factor with anime skins. It really can make the skin.

On this Winamp 5-star scale, I'd give you 2 stars. Possibly 2 and a half.

You should thank CO for his generosity.


------------------
[img]http://members.***********/~ShizNat99/banner3.gif[/img]

***Quality Anime Skins***

http://members.***********/~ShizNat99/mskin.html

[This message has been edited by Zeruel (edited October 31, 2000).]

Oh the acid! It burns! It Burns! http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/wink.gif

Ok, then Points Taken. Maybe the Volume, Position And Balance Are Floating Thats True and Before U said this i was Working on Some Ocupancy effects to Sort this Out Coz i hated Them Floating there, Yup the text Isnt original But Like before Iv altered that too.
And As 4 Editing the Pic hehe i son't think so. I spent Hours days even in my spare time Trying to Line Up The Eye Piece As the random Button Cutting and Pasting Screen Captures.
Also, Again I ask the member there -did U download my skin- have a Play around with it, Out of all the faults Uv Picked I ask Did u notice the Work on the eye piece (I know its not amazing but its original At least Give Me that)

Also to the Moderator I am sorry to Post this U must See 1000s Of these But Come on i don't Care Iv Seen loads Of 4 star Skins (of subjects I love more Than GitS) which Have More Of the Above Problems As Mine.
I'll Sort some of it Out and resubmit it.
Thanks 4 ye Time

PS, The English Skills An't good I know but This is Just a forum not a English Exam http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/rolleyes.gif

Ok, buddy...you gotta understand something here...making the image lined up with certain skin functions IS NOT image-editing. That's image-placement. So like I said, you have done no image-editing. Period.

But fix it up a bit...no wait, try to do another skin. And take those points into account. Good luck.

However, i would still venture to say that placement is 50% of the battle with a skin that uses a picture focus. 50% doesn't win
the war though... http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/wink.gif

http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/eek.gif Xerxes http://forums.winamp.com/ubb/eek.gif

Oh I agree. Image placement is *extremely* important. But, it's still not image-EDITING. That was my point.