Winamp & Shoutcast Forums

Winamp & Shoutcast Forums (http://forums.winamp.com/index.php)
-   Classic Skins (http://forums.winamp.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Work in progress, need your opinion (http://forums.winamp.com/showthread.php?t=54817)

Mr_Tough_Guy 13th July 2001 20:54

I started work on a new skin, but I'm not sure it's all working out
http://members.spree.com/sci-fi/comk...tarwars2ss.gif

for one I really wanted to keep the Cbuttons simple and small so I wouldn't cover the pic under it, so I went with tiny transparant white buttons, cept when I started on the shuffrep, I realized they don't really fit with the rest of the skin. So before I wast any time, it already takes me long enough to make a skin, I wanted to ask your opinion.

iverssson 13th July 2001 20:58

Has anybody ever told any other"skin lover" to stop working on a projet because it was ugly???

I didnt think so, and it wont start today, I like the skin, very cool, nice layer working and with all pic skins, CButtons are always small.

You're right about the Suffle button, it doesnt go. If you dont mind me asking, who is on the skin?

the controls in the vis area is cool you should do that for shuf/rep.... have it start out as a rounded square, and animate it to open.....

Just a few suggetion, feel free not to listen.

Mr_Tough_Guy 13th July 2001 23:24

the more I think about it the more I think about changing the shuffrep, though I'm not sure I really like the Cbuttons either, Oh well, maybe if I sleep on it the right answer will come to me.

BTW the gal in the pic is natalie Portman, in her Star Wars episode 2 costume, it's a Star wars skin, just havn't decided yet where to put the star wars logo.

dekt 13th July 2001 23:33

My suggestion for the cbuttons comes from what you've done for the OAIDV - blue circles with a grey edge. You could maybe make them turn yellow for the pressed state? I just think making the controls more neutral (ie not yellow) means they don't distract from the images as much.

Keep going though and with Natalie Portman on it you'll end up with a very popular skin.:)

Mr_Tough_Guy 14th July 2001 00:23

Thought about doing that, but didn't do it cause I thought it might cover the pic too much, Oh well might as well try it, if i don't like it i've always got those small buttons as a backup plan.

Mr_Tough_Guy 14th July 2001 01:51

http://members.spree.com/sci-fi/comk...tarwars2ss.jpg

did some more work on the titlebar and tried something else with the Cbuttons, still not completly happy since it partially covers an eye, though I don't think I can do much about that short of redoing just about everything I've done so far and move the head.

anyway I'm calling it quits for tonight since it's almost 4 am.

garetjax 14th July 2001 01:52

Ideas..for ya
 
Well, I'd say to make the numbers.bmp/num_ex.bmp transparent type, using the color area you have defined.

As for the cbutton row...I think the current buttons are very good but, perhaps, using a 1pixel wide white hue that ecompasses the whole of the cbutton row would be enough to seperate it. I'm not very good at making skins so perhaps, my input is not as beneficial as it would seem. As for the Shuf/Rep I personally like them even though they are indeed different than the cbutton row. However, functionally they are a great deal different and perhaps, having them set apart is a great idea.

Anyways, its a great start as far as pic skins go...however, not much in the way of new or innovation that I can see...but, again what do I know.

-Joe W. Garrett

Mr. Bojanglez 14th July 2001 02:56

hmmm
 
i would say it sucked but we can't have flame wars brewing, but what do I know about skinning?

Mr Jones 14th July 2001 09:25

LOL, BO, I've never seen you say you like ANYONES skins, can you point us towards what you do like?, I'm curious.


Back on topic....

I like, SW rocks, but as a "former" image skinner myself, I know what your going thru with those buttons, WA3 is gonna be such a blessing for image skinners :D

Keep up the good work fella, looking forward to the end results :)

Lucid DM 14th July 2001 12:15

Thing is Mr Jones. There are gonna be a *lot* of pic skins that are huge. Not file size, but actual screen space.
Ah well. As long as the pic is good :D

dekt 14th July 2001 19:49

Quote:

There are gonna be a *lot* of pic skins that are huge. Not file size, but actual screen space.
I can see that going the same way some SoundJam skins have with the controls in a 'plinth' with the character/person standing/lying on top.

Only other suggestion for Mr_Tough_Guy is 'barely there' buttons - like the original ones but with no edge and paler (they might look a bit skinner-ish though). Or trace the corners/edges of the actual button areas very faintly and have the symbol appear only when it's pressed?

Mr. Bojanglez 14th July 2001 20:54

I don't hate everybodie's skins
 
nope there are some of the skins that I like contrary to popular belief so here is my top ten list.


1. Auriga-Kinwashi's
2. Major Tom- by that one guy
3. Zues by that one guy
4. Relic- Again by some author who I forgot his name
5. Antigusta- the one I am working on
6. Adidas- I think its one of the ones under sports category on main skins page
7. This one called flash that I seen at 1001
8. This hitachi one I seen at 1001
9. This orange and black one that I accidentaly deleted and forgot its name
10. Finally one made by a fellow skin lovin' forumite- that one batman one

Well those are the ones that fall in my top ten

Mr. Bojanglez 14th July 2001 20:58

.....
 
o yea those were in order

Mr_Tough_Guy 15th July 2001 01:59

http://members.spree.com/sci-fi/comk...arwars2ss2.jpg
decided to move the head anyway, took me about 2 hours to fix the damage I did because I hadn't saved all the layers. looks a lot better though if i do say so myself.

chiquita chad 15th July 2001 03:03

Mr Bo, im guessing you've never heard of any of these skins huh?:
War Games
Xperienze
Xqwizit
Devil Ant
Divine
V-Max
Nemish
Raj Amp (all versions)
Razor Amp
SnipeAmp Pro
SnipeAmp
or Science

those are my top 10, well 12, fave skins (in order)

ampburner 15th July 2001 12:40

:) ( ;) )

dekt 15th July 2001 15:22

Sounds like a good topic for a thread...
 
Just did searches on winamp for most of these and got nothing. Could you please post some URLs for the likes of war games, xperienze, devil ant, divine, v-max, raj amp (I've already been to ampburner's site so I know his)?

ampburner 15th July 2001 15:58

v-max is mine aswell :)

dekt 15th July 2001 20:21

oops! :o
 
Sorry, it's the new red one with the black 'n white check isn't it?

*Looks up ampburner's site* Uh-huh, I knew it by its proper name 'Maximum Veocity', I wasn't on first name terms with it.:)

ampburner 15th July 2001 20:25

:)

The Only Lynx 15th July 2001 20:32

mr bo.. why you say at your #10 "finally skin love" your number 1 is also by skin love.. our own kiniwashi!!!

and i am sad to see not my woodshop in a top ten.. but i hope it is somewhere in your top 100 ;)

Mr. Bojanglez 16th July 2001 05:13

hmm
 
ampburner- I especially hate your v-max skin, but the summer skin one was ok.

Lynx-I've only seen one of your skins, I don't think I've ever seen woody's shop

And kinwashi maybe a skin lover forumite person but I hardly see him here, and he barely has any post at winamp 3 diss., also the aim name i saw at deviant art kinwashi2, he's never on that, i took ICQ off my computer so i don't know if he has that, i haven't seen a skin from him in a while cept the winamp3 one, so basically i never hear him, never see him, i don't even ever smell him, just like the zeus guy, therefore i count him as not here.

(But if you are here post a reply and lemme see)


No Tv messages this time, Popeye is too boring.

iverssson 16th July 2001 05:57

Mr Tough Guy

I like your eq sliders...mind if i rip them sometime? I mean borrow ;)

i see the Natalie Portman thing now...sorry, that comes out next year right? along with Matrix 2 [yeah!]

Adding my 2 cents on favorites...

Merdian [bluer one]
Breed Amp [Usability issues arise]
Bio Alloy [Usability issues arise]
Hand Written
Liquid Paradise [simple, but looks nice]
RazorAmp [already mentioned numerous times above]
Prime Orange [from deviant art, many other colors too]
Vince Freestyle [because I like pictures, and this was the best one i had done, and I dont mind shameless plugs (Hope you dont either)]

Not in that order, but they are all cool. My tastes vary, and I usually look at the totally new designs....I love Raj I/O's work as well....

[Edited by iverssson on 07-16-2001 at 02:13 AM]

Mr. Bojanglez 16th July 2001 06:21

hmmmmm
 
well whats your least favorite skin?


mine is that darn britney spears one in the nost popular category

iverssson 16th July 2001 06:24

Re: hmmmmm
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Bojanglez
well whats your least favorite skin?


mine is that darn britney spears one in the nost popular category

Anything by John Sledgers....[lol]
Ok just kidding [kind of]

But any skinner skin out there with no attention to detail, or no "love" given to it.

Even the Britnay Spears skin in the most popular skin is better than all those skinner skins out there....
3-3.5 for britnay, most of the stars go for effort and love given to it by the author...

ampburner 16th July 2001 12:01

Re: hmm
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Bojanglez
ampburner- I especially hate your v-max skin, but the
I hate yours equally :D Actually, no I don't... hate is too strong a word.
Apathy would be more like it.

Mr Jones 16th July 2001 12:06

http://www.btinternet.com/~harveynj101/stuff/apath.gif

ampburner 16th July 2001 12:14

LOL

simon snowflake 16th July 2001 13:21

Hey MR B, how do you think of my croq-amp?
:D

Lucid DM 16th July 2001 14:43

What's the difference between ignorance and apathy?


I don't know and I don't care.

ampburner 16th July 2001 16:34

You answered your own Q :D:D:D:D

ignorance=don't know
apathy=don't care

:p

Mr_Tough_Guy 16th July 2001 21:29

Quote:

Originally posted by iverssson
Mr Tough Guy

I like your eq sliders...mind if i rip them sometime? I mean borrow ;)

i see the Natalie Portman thing now...sorry, that comes out next year right? along with Matrix 2 [yeah!]

Thanx, I kinda like them myself, best EQ sliders I have ever made. Feel free to do all kinds of unspeakable acts with them

And yes Star Wars 2 will be out next year probably may 2002

http://members.spree.com/sci-fi/comk...arwars2ss3.jpg
Still not sure what to do with the shuffrep, but in the meantime I've finished the volume and balance bars.

Guess my favourite skin is act2 Finale by Raj.I/O
not really fond of metal skins, in fact I think I only have picture skins, and Act2 Finale is kinda on the edge

BullGawD 16th July 2001 22:26

MTG - I hate to say it, but I don't like any of your buttons or sliders. Well, let me rephrase that. I don't like them in conjunction with the background image you have, which is quite nice.

What I don't like - the colors, and the disjointed nature. What about perhaps a beveled area to tie all those buttons together? like in this skin. Heh, I know the material isn't exactly the same, but it was the first one that came to mind. But even if you don't want to do that, you'd win me over if you'd increase the transparency on your buttons, or change their color scheme to something more in keeping witht the orangish/black colors you have going.

Just my two cents, a day late and a dollar short.

Oh, and why not put the star wars logo: In the vis area, on the EQ titlebar, above the songname bar, or in the volume/balance area? If you did that, you could do a moving highlight for your volume slider.

Anyway. just ideas. I'll understand if you disregard them, seeing how you've already done a few updates. Keep us posted. :D

Mr_Tough_Guy 17th July 2001 20:19

Thanx for the input BullGawD, your right the Buttons and sliders don't really fit with the background, The thing is I always have trouble with the equalizer sliders, and I usually end up with something really simple, So this time I really wanted to do something special, and after seeing a Star wars pic that had some sliders in it I decided to base them on that. When I finished the sliders however I did notice they didn't really fit. But I didn't want to trow away the slider or the background, I even thought about doing 2 separate skins, but in the end it kinda grew on me and I decided to go with it as was.

anywho I'll keep your suggestions in mind

Mr_Tough_Guy 25th July 2001 21:55

Finally did some more work on it
http://members.spree.com/sci-fi/comk...arwars2ss4.jpg

decided to pretty much go with the shuffrep as I had planned, though changed it from round to regtangular, still not really happy though, thinking of doing em over in the same style as the cbuttons, what do you think?

simon snowflake 25th July 2001 22:00

can you post a pic with the round ones?

and i think it would indeed be better to do them the same style as your Cbuttons

Mr_Tough_Guy 25th July 2001 22:05

check the first pic in my first post with a round version, it's only the repeat part, but you can see where I was going.

Mr. Bojanglez 25th July 2001 22:40

hmm
 
the girl in the eq looks like she has a crook in her back...

Nini 26th July 2001 08:59

hey mr tough guy :)
You skin has changed a lot and I think in the positive direction :)
I like the blace of the SW logo but I'd move it some pixels to the right, away from Natalie's face.
Ah. and the cuttleBar is a bit too bright for me...maybe make it more transparnt, just like the cbuttons?
no idea for shufrep...but more transparency could be better...;)
PS Make sure to post a link here when ypu're finished ...coz I think it's a very nice skin...don't wanna miss it :)

Mr. Bojanglez 26th July 2001 11:18

hmm
 
am i the only one that noticed?

that natalie girl isn't standing the right way..

she has a crook in her back..


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:19.

Copyright © 1999 - 2010 Nullsoft. All Rights Reserved.