i wildrose..once again..i uploaded this skin(135504) on monday and i still dun get a message if it is published or there is any problem with it. Could you ckeck it please?
thanx alot!
Sakura Lite is unpublished because it doesnt have an eq... the skin was never designed to have an eq and since the skin its self is now a dead project i just wanna get finnished... there isnt going to be an eq... i dont see why i NEED an eq since everything else needed is there
It presents us with a problem, I was gonna message you about this tonight, but you beat me to it.
We layed down a minimum spec some time ago to improve the quality of the skins in the database, this spec was agreed by the powers that be, they kind of think that the EQ is an integral part of the player and really should be included, either as a seperate window, or built into some other part of the skin..
See, now if we let sakura lite on, then we have to start letting others with no eq on as well, can't have one rule for one, and one for another.
Couldn't you piece together a simple EQ as a seperate window?, you have a simple plain standard frame layout, wouldn't take long to piece together a basic EQ for it.
I've spoken with other reviewers, and they agree, we can't go bending rules for one, or everyone would be lining up to bend them,and we would then end up with a crappy half baked skin database.
ok then.... winamp.com doesnt want it, i can find much better places to put it..
also.. how can you say if a skin is compleat or not? winamp3 skins are freeform, thus are compleat when the designer says they are.. you should judge on the quality of the skin not its content
At the end of the day, it's still a skin for a media player, and the owners of this site want the skin on it to reflect that and be as functional as possible, and for some reason, they seem to think the EQ is a integral part of the media player experience, hence why we look for it in any skins that are published.
The freefrom argument dosn't hold when you talking about minimum standards, if that was the case, I'd submit my test area skin that is a 300x300 black square with a single play/pause button in the middle of it.
Comment