No announcement yet.

Corrupt listings on Shoutcast-website

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Corrupt listings on Shoutcast-website


    The listings on ... are:

    Corrupt , Wrong , Incorrect


    I check a certain station ... on its DNAS status page it says:

    Stream Status: Stream is up with 156 of 999 listeners (54 unique)

    I then immidiatly also check website where it says:

    156 listeners

    Ofcourse i have verified this several times on different moments of the day
    over a period of a few weeks ... and also have taken in account any delays and
    averaging that obviously takes place.


    The website is corrupt ... since it lists all listeners including
    doublures or triple listening from the same ip-adress ... ie: stations that use tricks
    such as multiple players on a pc ...etc ... to fraudulently / artificially inflate their
    listener-numbers can get away with it ...and shoutcast is helping them.

    This puts back honest stations that don't use tricks like this !

    How difficult can it be .. if the dnas already shows the real number of UNIQUE listeners
    to let the website listing also use only the UNIQUE number of listeners ?

    I don't think that i'm the first one to notice this why in the world don't you repair this ?
    Why do you help fraudsters ? ... there cant be no excuses to let this exist ..
    If you have a listing like this the first thing one expects is that it is more or less correct & honest.

    Listing on the website should be based on UNIQUE nr of listeners !

    It must be sooooo simple to repair this
    you are disrespecting honest stations by letting this exist.

    Attached Files

  • #2
    To sum it up:


    As mentioned above ... there are stations that use tricks or bad webplayer design
    which cause a inflation of the number of listeners ... they may do this on purpose
    or in ignorancy (they don't even know it happens)

    From my research usually it comes down to triple-ing the real numbers
    ie: theres for example 50 UNIQUE LISTENERS
    and they manage to somehow 3-fold this number ... so it shows 150 CURRENT LISTENERS
    for some mysterious or on purpose reason is using the CURRENT LISTENERS
    value instead of the UNIQUE LISTENERS value ... thus helping the fraudsters.


    UNIQUE LISTENERS ... indicates the number of ip-adresses that are listening,
    it will not take in account if people are using 10 or 100
    fake players , rippers or whatever on a same ip-address to inflate their listener numbers.
    ie: UNIQUE LISTENERS will allways show 1 listener per ip-adress.

    This is a much more fair indication and a representation of the truth.


    The listing can take the UNIQUE LISTENER from either:

    admin.cgi?mode=viewxml&page=1 (DNAS status that includes UNIQUE LISTENER stats)

    or from

    The XML-feed ... as described here

    which also includes UNIQUE LISTENER stats.

    This will take only a few minutes to program in the source of the
    or database that it is connected to ... unless it is a mess (usually the case).


    There is no reason why the listening should not show nr of listeners

    So make it UNIQUE LISTENERS !

    I don't get it why you have the door open wide for fraude
    i cant believe you do not know about this ... so there´s probably a bad excuse for it
    to solve some other problem ... its bad programming of the worse kind.


    Some stations (like me) work around the clock to create a good station with real audience
    I myself have spend maybe 150000 hours on it ... pay everything from my own pocket.

    Now comes some criminal (or ignorant) ... he doesnt do anything to improve his station
    so he inflates his listener-numbers and therefore his rank on and as a result
    also on another 500 portals and apps who base their ranking on (API) , and therefore will get even more listeners (high rank means seen-first) ... that's how a small variation has big effects.


    Here´s an example of a trick to triple your listener-numbers ... its simple:

    You build your radio-website ... you put 3 embedded players on it (for example jPlayer)

    You hide 2 of them (invisible) and set their audio-volume to zero.
    The other one visible player controls all 3 players ... and voila each single listener
    that comes to your website and hits the playbutton will now cause 3 streams
    and that is what shoutcast will show ...pfff !

    You could also have 10 hidden embedded players on any website (under your control)
    you set them all to autoplay and volume = 0 .. now theres 10 listeners showing up on

    Visitor will usually not notice much since 3 or 10 times 128kbs is nothing these days.

    Above trick is much better then having 25 instances of winamp or streamripper
    on your own pc ... but that could be done too .. there must be 10´s of ways to do it.

    In addition (nothing to do with tricks) many mobile phones (both iOs & Android)
    and some browsers can not handle streams very well and they may open several streams at the sametime ... instead of the intended only one ... this is not on purpose but bad design of the embedded player i have studied this in extent ... yes even welknown players.

    All of the above can be solved by using UNIQUE LISTENERS


    Its an important issue ... so i would expect a reply from
    or from one of the devs / mods here.

    Thank you for your attention


    • #3
      excellent points -- i totally agree -- there are more reasons why unique listeners are a more accurate reflection, than an erroneous undercount -- only the powers that be know why gross client connections are publicized over unique clients.
      /* v2 HTML5 / Player test pages DigitalMixNYC, DigitalMixNYCbx | DNAS Status: Now Playing js codes (scaststatus_X.php) | | Upload/Download Speed Test | Free Dynamic DNS | In the YP | dnasDir */


      • #4
        I would appreciate some reply from shoutcast-staff
        or moderator or one of the oldtimers here.

        Why does it take so long to get some "official" reply ?

        If this is not the right place to inquire or complain about this ... let me know.


        • #5
          So can i should conclude that there is absolutely no support from shoutcast ?
          and none of the moderators will help or say anything usefull ?
          Even if I say there is fraude going on ... nobody is interested ?


          • #6
            How can i correct a message ?
            when i posted for the first time in this forum it said
            "not allowed to edit posts" ... i don't see that anymore
            but still i cant edit it .. how to edit ?


            • #7
              Sorry to say but what a useless shit forum !
              everything shoutcast (and radionomy) allways sucks
              obviously that includes those that work for it cause they are the company
              ha ha ... keep on trying to get people to sign-up for your monitizing services
              never ever will i spend a single dime on such a shitcompany ... with ZERO SUPPORT.
              and who doesn´t give a damn about their users ... it is so stupid to waiste a product
              like that ... the owners must be total fools.